depends on the internal resistance of the battery
a battery with lower internal resistance will supply a higher current over a short time per volt
a battery with a higer internal resistance will supply less current for a longer time per volt
as it is powering a solinoid coil the coil requires a high inrush current to pull it closed but a small holding current to keep it closed
im guessing the Energiser battery is one of the types for light usage like remote controls
and the duracell is the type for cameras with heavey current demands
dont try to measure resistance of the battery with a multymeter you will probably kill it
a battery with lower internal resistance will supply a higher current over a short time per volt
a battery with a higer internal resistance will supply less current for a longer time per volt
as it is powering a solinoid coil the coil requires a high inrush current to pull it closed but a small holding current to keep it closed
im guessing the Energiser battery is one of the types for light usage like remote controls
and the duracell is the type for cameras with heavey current demands
dont try to measure resistance of the battery with a multymeter you will probably kill it