hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Printable Version +- 306oc - Peugeot 306 Owners Club & Forum (https://www.306oc.co.uk/forum) +-- Forum: Engines (https://www.306oc.co.uk/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=16) +--- Forum: DW10 HDi section (https://www.306oc.co.uk/forum/forumdisplay.php?fid=10) +--- Thread: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo (/showthread.php?tid=12520) Pages:
1
2
|
hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 04-04-2013 which one is the best? how do you know if its a hdi dturbo? want one for power and comfort, found a lovely hdi dturbo for 700 euro, very tempting, just need to know which would be better for me? any help greatly appreciated, thanks RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Toms306 - 04-04-2013 DTurbo is just a trim level. Cloth sports seats and GTi suspension basically. The engine choice is 2.0 HDi (common rail) or 1.9 XUD (mechanical injection). They are both 90bhp as standard so neither are exactly powerful. DTurbo's arent particularly comfy either, you want a meridian for comfort really, softer suspension and half leather seats, as well as a leather steering wheel and gear knob. The HDi can be remapped for more power. The XUD fuel pump can be tweaked for more power. So really it depends on the person as to which is 'best'. RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 08:41 PM)Toms306 Wrote: DTurbo is just a trim level. Cloth sports seats and GTi suspension basically. thanks for the info, well the power wikk be a big change from a 1.0 corsa b, are the powerhdi bad on electrics or anything? have they got torsion bars in the hdi`s? bit of a stupid question ha RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Oil-burner - 04-04-2013 Do what I did, buy a hdi dturbo and put leather seats in it. RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 08:56 PM)Oil-burner Wrote: Do what I did, buy a hdi dturbo and put leather seats in it. was thinkin of stripping back of it out and 2 reclining bucket seats and harnesses, will be handy for the dogs aswel being stripped out, are they any good standard?without being chipped? RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - sweeney1987 - 04-04-2013 what happened to the 1.4 project that i see for sale in bits? Hdi is more refined, economy. Dturbos easier to tune, more fun to play with. either way tax is a killer on both! RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 09:07 PM)sweeney1987 Wrote: what happened to the 1.4 project that i see for sale in bits? petrol would cost me a bomb, and id just rather a diesel, tax is ridiculous, but i should be okay :-D insurance is cheaper than what im paying on the 1 litre, so is a hdi a good buy? RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Toms306 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 09:04 PM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote:(04-04-2013, 08:56 PM)Oil-burner Wrote: Do what I did, buy a hdi dturbo and put leather seats in it. I thought you wanted comfort!? Tbh you should do a bit of research/searching on here really. Power is in the eye of the driver, I've always hated how slow HDis are lol, but from a 1.0 Corsa maybe they'll seem quick! That said, if you can flash a map and know the right people you can up the power to around 120bhp for like £20, which is 'enough' really, not quick, but makes it driveable at least lol. If you like fiddling with screws and getting covered in crap you can tweak the XUD yourself for the same kinda power. As for torsion bars, yes all 306's have those. RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - sweeney1987 - 04-04-2013 can be troublesome, look at how many whats wrong with my hdi threads there are on here... injectors, high pressure and low pressure fuel pumps and fuel rail pressure sensors can all go typical modern car problems really, more electrics more faults out of interest what car is this? if its the one im thinking of i just got offered it for 500 RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 09:16 PM)sweeney1987 Wrote: can be troublesome, look at how many whats wrong with my hdi threads there are on here... is that every hdi or just yours? Haha ah no would i be better of wit a dturbo? hard to find a nice 3door one, a black 3door one? RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - sweeney1987 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 09:19 PM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote:mine hasnt seen the road since i drove it home haha.(04-04-2013, 09:16 PM)sweeney1987 Wrote: can be troublesome, look at how many whats wrong with my hdi threads there are on here... busy at college to fix it up, still driving a 406. Really upto yourself and what you need or want. say thats one im thinking of, havent looked at it but may look at it tomoro RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 09:15 PM)Toms306 Wrote:(04-04-2013, 09:04 PM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote:(04-04-2013, 08:56 PM)Oil-burner Wrote: Do what I did, buy a hdi dturbo and put leather seats in it. (04-04-2013, 09:23 PM)sweeney1987 Wrote:dont buy it!!!!!!!!!!! Haha i want it ha :-D so much trouble wit yours do you really want another one Haha :-D(04-04-2013, 09:19 PM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote:mine hasnt seen the road since i drove it home haha.(04-04-2013, 09:16 PM)sweeney1987 Wrote: can be troublesome, look at how many whats wrong with my hdi threads there are on here... RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Poodle - 04-04-2013 HDis really aren't that slow tom, you just buy broken ones. :p And ok they have their issues, but there's similar stereotpes for XUDs - headgaskets or rust for example. 700 euros seems a damn good price to me, perhaps too good - what's wrong with it haha. HDi dturbos are meant to have slightly lower suspension too i think. RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 04-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 09:55 PM)Poodle Wrote: HDis really aren't that slow tom, you just buy broken ones. :p needs service and few other things, and timing belt to be safe :-D RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - lolsteve - 04-04-2013 Hdi's may have their electric problems, but it beats throwing a rod and having the contents of your engine all over the road RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Poodle - 05-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 11:14 PM)lolsteve Wrote: Hdi's may have their electric problems, but it beats throwing a rod and having the contents of your engine all over the road QFT. Ah that's not too bad, got to be worth it imho. RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Piggy - 05-04-2013 xud nuff said RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - sweeney1987 - 05-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 09:24 PM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote: dont buy it!!!!!!!!!!! Haha i want it ha :-D so much trouble wit yours do you really want another one Haha :-Dno trouble with mine at all, just not had time to put it road worthy, no nct or tax on it at minute like. as i said i only drove it home (04-04-2013, 10:05 PM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote:did you ring her?(04-04-2013, 09:55 PM)Poodle Wrote: HDis really aren't that slow tom, you just buy broken ones. :p i was only messaging through adverts n she dropped price fairly quick, seems eager to sell n not a lot of interest, makes me think smething is lurking underneath RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 05-04-2013 (05-04-2013, 08:56 AM)sweeney1987 Wrote:(04-04-2013, 09:24 PM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote: dont buy it!!!!!!!!!!! Haha i want it ha :-D so much trouble wit yours do you really want another one Haha :-Dno trouble with mine at all, just not had time to put it road worthy, no nct or tax on it at minute like. as i said i only drove it home ya i was thinking that meself, it looks fairly clean though, timing belt is due alright and needs service and few other things, but i dont want to travel up there and it be a ball of shit ha RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - sweeney1987 - 05-04-2013 (05-04-2013, 10:27 AM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote: ya i was thinking that meself, it looks fairly clean though, timing belt is due alright and needs service and few other things, but i dont want to travel up there and it be a ball of shit ha yeah, nothing as bad as travelling to see a yoke n it be shite, before i bought 406 i have now, went look at a different one that was shite, lad wanted 900, dropped to 850, 97, 196k, less nct than he said, more miles than advertised, drivers window broke n bushings hanging a sunder. then he had the cheek to say i was wasting his time!!!! was only going to look at that 306 as its practically on me way home haha RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 05-04-2013 (05-04-2013, 10:48 AM)sweeney1987 Wrote:(05-04-2013, 10:27 AM)tysonbully2k12 Wrote: ya i was thinking that meself, it looks fairly clean though, timing belt is due alright and needs service and few other things, but i dont want to travel up there and it be a ball of shit ha haha some idiots out there ha ah sure if you feel the need to have a look and dont want to buy it you can tell me if its a ball of shit haha RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Ruan - 05-04-2013 (04-04-2013, 11:14 PM)lolsteve Wrote: Hdi's may have their electric problems, but it beats throwing a rod and having the contents of your engine all over the road At least an XUD does it properly, a HDi you'll have a thousand fault codes, need a new lift pump, need a new FRPS, injectors rattling, immobiliser deicded to forget itself etc etc. If you can name a rod being bust on an XUD below 140hp in the past year I'll be impressed... It's so uncommon in the grand scheme of things... There's a thread near enough weekly on a HDi not starting.. RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - rd070707 - 05-04-2013 hdi's have their common electrical faults / fuel system but again these only seem common as most common folk don't have a clue what to do and threads are started over and over again. At least with stronger internals you dont have to rebuild the engine or change head gaskets etc which for me isn't really viable RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - lolsteve - 05-04-2013 (05-04-2013, 12:09 PM)Ruan Wrote:(04-04-2013, 11:14 PM)lolsteve Wrote: Hdi's may have their electric problems, but it beats throwing a rod and having the contents of your engine all over the road I did have like a thousand faults codes as Niall said when he plugged pp2000 in the ecu was nearly full. After a quick wipe and cleaning fpr haven't had any engine problems since. But once you go over 140.. then you're in rod territory? Once you go there with hdi worst people seem to get is a cut out which is like rod throwing but without the Mario kart oil slick And yes we may need new lift pumps now and then but it beats a warped head now does it haha RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Mattcheese31 - 05-04-2013 1905cc XUD . . . spoke to a few mechanics that reckon HDI was the worst thing they ever did to that engine . . . .and i agree RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Poodle - 05-04-2013 Ah, but it was still running with all those fault codes wasn't it?! Yeah fair point Ru, i suppose the odd electrical issue does completely outweigh all the benefits of direct injection and ecu control - economy, power, refinement, etc. Besides, the only really big power diesel round here was Darrens and that's a XUD, OWAIT! :p Matt, you're beginning to show your age mate. RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - sweeney1987 - 05-04-2013 you buy it? She just text me saying it was sold... RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - tysonbully2k12 - 05-04-2013 (05-04-2013, 05:43 PM)sweeney1987 Wrote: you buy it? She just text me saying it was sold... no i didnt buy it, thought you did, she text me too, ah sure id say twas a ball of shit ill wait for a d turbo i think your not selling one no?? RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Piggy - 05-04-2013 (05-04-2013, 03:04 PM)Mattcheese31 Wrote: 1905cc XUD . . . spoke to a few mechanics that reckon HDI was the worst thing they ever did to that engine . . . .and i agree I second this. 140+ and you mean have rod issues...but not all do. and with a hdi over 140+ and you huge clutch issues! 2.0hdi....worst thing they did imo RE: hdi, hdi dturbo or dturbo - Mattcheese31 - 05-04-2013 (05-04-2013, 05:41 PM)Poodle Wrote: Ah, but it was still running with all those fault codes wasn't it?! nope, i own both engines mate, and i know which i prefer, the age thing just gives me the wisdom to know which is best . . . |